Give your kids the gift of no student debt
By Garry Marr, Financial PostDecember 12, 2009
There is no end to the selection of presents you can give your child this holiday season, but how about the gift of no student debt?
Though it may lack the fanfare of RRSP season, the end of year should be considered Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) time. The deadline for contributing to an RESP, and getting the grant for the year, is Dec. 31, possibly the worst time of the year for those who are already strapped for cash.
"The deadline for RESPs is a little different because you can actually contribute in one year and get two years worth of grants," explains David Sharone, product manager of registered plans at the Bank of Montreal.
Basically, for every $2,500 you contribute per child you can get a $500 grant. You are allowed to contribute two years at a time, but the grants stop at the child's age 17. So there is a time limit to get the maximum $7,200 in lifetime grants.
"If you are starting at age 14, you'll never catch up on time. If they're nine or younger, you can catch up," says Mr. Sharone.
The question is, where to get the cash? Anybody who has a disabled child also must be thinking carefully about a Registered Disability Savings Plan, which can result in $3,500 in grants for a minimal $1,500 in contributions, based on income.
It's still too early to say whether the one-year-old Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) has had a significant impact on parents contributing to their children's RESP. Adults (18 and over) can put up to $5,000 per year into a TFSA and thus shield any capital gains or interest from the tax-man, even after the funds are withdrawn from the account.
Statistics from the federal department show RESP contribution rose to $3.05-billion in 2008 from $2.97-billion the year before. There are no numbers for 2009, the first year the TFSA was offered.
"TFSA could work for planning for your child's education but it does not come with the grants," says Mr. Sharone.
"People are lost and they don't know what to do," says Kurt Rosentreter, a financial advisor with Manulife Securities Inc., commenting on the various options available today. "I was just on a call with a couple who just bought a house and they wanted to know whether they should accelerate their payments, put more in an RRSP, buy more life insurance or put it in an RESP."
Mr. Rosentreter says you need to look at the returns. If your mortgage rate is 5% on an after-tax basis, that's more like 7% or 8%. "Putting money into an RRSP and buying a 1% GIC is probably not the right thing to do this year," he says.
If you use the same logic with an RESP, you are getting a 20% grant and there is really no investment that can compete with that type of return.
He says Canadians have become more conservative in their approach to investing in an RESP and that makes little or no sense if your child is under age five -- an age where you should have 100% exposure to equities, because there is a long time horizon.
"No matter what happens in the stock market, how else are you going to beat that 20% return? The RESP is the thing to do above everything else," says Mr. Rosentreter.
---
Dusty wallet It's been 10 years since RESPs took off in popularity thanks to government grants. Canadians are now starting to access the cash. How you withdraw the money can affect your tax hit. An educational assistance payment (EAP) withdrawal, made up of the growth in the plan plus any grants and bonds, is taxable in the hands of the beneficiary. A post-secondary education withdrawal (PSE), made up of contributions already taxed, are not hit a second time when withdrawn. Most of the time you want to get the EAP money out first, especially if your child has no income. Plus, if you use up all the grants and your child quits school, the grants and bonds don't have to be paid back. The PSE withdrawal strategy would make sense if your child has high income, perhaps from a summer job